There are an awful lot of controversies when it comes to child-raising. Breastfeeding or formula, co-sleeping or in the crib, pick the baby up right away when he/she cries or let them cry it out.
I’m still sorting my feelings on the “crying it out” issue. Overall I’m a subscriber to the “pick them up when they cry,” at least in the first few months. I know that’s not really practical for everyone. I have the luxury of being a full-time stay-at-home mom with no other major responsibilities, so it’s almost always possible for me to pick Jack up when he’s crying.
Some people think you need to teach babies to be independent and they’ll quickly learn to settle themselves, so you need to let them cry a little. And some people think that by responding quickly every time they cry, the baby learns to feel safer and that someone will always be there for them, so they are actually more independent.
Clearly there’s no way to prove one way or the other, since you can’t do it both ways on the same baby, and clearly there are examples of emotionally sound adults who were raised in both ways. So does it matter?
Who knows. And who knows how long I will follow this. I think at least til he’s 3 months. It doesn’t mean I have picked him up EVERY time; sometimes I’m in the middle of doing something, like he’s in the car seat and I’m loading the car, and I know once the car’s moving he’ll be fine. Or I’m in the bathroom, or have my hands full.
I know there’s a middle ground: let him cry a little bit but a) not all the time and b) not if he’s really upset and c) not for too long. And he cries plenty when I’m holding him; it’s not like that automatically makes him better.
No conclusions on this, just some thoughts.